Right to Access Social Assistance
Play audio version
Indonesian Social Assistance Policy Ignores the Existence of Individuals with Psychosocial Disabilities
August 2, 2022
Translated from Bahasa Indonesia.
Click here for the Bahasa Indonesia version of this article.
JAKARTA, Indonesia — “Bambang,” an Indonesian Mental Health Association (IMHA) member with schizophrenia who wishes to remain anonymous, faces a dilemma. He is unemployed, but because he lives with his mother and sister in a house on the edge of a major road in Jakarta, he is ineligible for public social assistance. While Bambang doesn’t work and has no income of his own, his eligibility for social assistance is based on his family’s income, not his own. Because his mother and sister live in a larger house in a wealthier part of town, they are considered too “rich” for him to qualify for assistance. This leaves Bambang dependent on others for his survival. If he lives with his family, he is denied social assistance; if he doesn’t live with his family, he will become homeless.
According to Yeni Rosa Damayanti, chairperson of IMHA (also known as Perhimpunan Jiwa Sehat), many Indonesians with disabilities are forced to live with family members – cousins, aunts, parents – in garages and in other less than ideal housing situations. Damayanti says government social protection schemes are usually based on the family, not the individual. To receive social assistance from the Indonesian government, a citizen undergoes the Integrated Social Welfare Management (DTKS) process. Registrants must not own property, a car, or live in a “rich” area, among other criteria. Since Bambang’s family home is valued at over 66,000 U.S. dollars, he is ineligible for government support. Such criteria deny assistance to many persons with disabilities.
The Right to Live Independently
Indonesian Law No. 8 of 2016 Article 17 guarantees the “right to social welfare for Persons with Disabilities [including] social rehabilitation, social insurance, social empowerment, and social protection,” and the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD) Article 19 recognizes the right of persons with disabilities to choose where they live with no obligation “to live in a particular living arrangement.” Overall, persons with disabilities have the right to live on their own – to not be dependent on anyone for their survival – but Indonesia’s social assistance policies make this all but impossible.
A 2020 survey led by the Disabled People’s Organization (DPO) Network for a More Inclusive Covid Response found that while 9 percent of Indonesians have a disability, only 3 percent receive regular social protection benefits. In a report accompanying the survey, the authors note that the voices of persons with disabilities are often missing in policymaking – even though this is a requirement of the UNCRPD.
Inaccessible Application Process
Adding to the problem is the fact that the DTKS website page is inaccessible; its performance is slow because millions of Jakarta inhabitants are accessing the website at the same time and because it shares servers with other ministries. DTKS registrants only have 30 days to sign up once the government announces registration re-opening periods. As a result of the website’s slow performance compounded by Jakarta’s population size, many people like Bambang do not have enough time to register before the deadline. During his registration period in February, Bambang tried to access the website multiple times until he gave up and finally registered with the help of a local government official.
First built in 2015, the Ministry of Social Affairs DTKS system includes data on Social Welfare Service Recipients (PPKS) for programs like the Family Home Program (PKH), Basic Food Assistance, and the Jakarta Persons with Disabilities Card (KPDJ), the latter of which Bambang sought but was denied. Today, he is left to make ends meet. He finds it difficult to find a job and seeks assistance from organizations of persons with disabilities like IMHA. “I don’t get cash assistance at all … I only get social assistance channeled through organizations,” Bambang says. He is not the only IMHA member facing this issue. Other IMHA members have been forced to live with families that the government does not recognize as poor enough to receive assistance.
Data collection inconsistencies in Indonesia add fuel to the flame. “The government must be more serious in taking care of this disability problem, starting from comprehensive and thorough data collection … There must be a reliable data unit that is used to distribute assistance that is the right of disability,” says Bambang. A study by the National Team for the Acceleration of Poverty Reduction (TNP2K) notes that access to social protection, one of the various rights persons with disabilities have without discrimination, tends to be limited for various reasons. These include limited data information related to disability in Indonesia. Such limited information reduces the urgency for the government to prioritize and allocate resources to persons with disabilities.
The study mentions persons with disability face challenges in accessing different birth certificates, too. A 2014 study conducted by a partnership between the Indonesian and Australian governments for programs endorsing the values of justice (AIPJ) found that inaccessible offices and “complicated procedures” make it hard for persons with disabilities to apply for and receive legal identity documents. Another 2017 study reveals that the main reason Indonesian children (with or without disabilities) do not have birth certificates, a required document to access services, is cost. Many parents also don’t realize the need for such a document – and that they are entitled to these public services. Although the TNP2K and Australian Government study says the Indonesian government has taken steps to increase access to birth certificates for all children, inaccessible government documents exacerbate the challenges persons with disabilities face when attempting to register for social assistance.
Bambang remains hopeful he will receive social assistance in the future: “I really deserve [the Jakarta Persons with Disabilities Card] KPDJ because I am a disabled person who requires more money.”
Kinanty Andini is a 2022 DJP fellow and affiliate with the Indonesian Mental Health Association (IMHA) also known as Perhimpunan Jiwa Sehat. @2022 Indonesian Mental Health Association (Perhimpunan Jiwa Sehat). All rights reserved.
News From the Global Frontlines of Disability Justice
DJP mentor Kishor Sharma is known for his long-term photography and film projects exploring community and change. Over the last 12 years, he has been documenting the nomadic Raute people in mountainous Nepal. With any project, Sharma aims to actively engage participants, sharing photography and videography techniques. In September, Sharma became a mentor to DJP fellow Chhitup Lama. He was eager to connect “this idea of sharing the visual technique with the storytelling idea and the issue of disability inclusion.”
Over the summer the DJP trained Indigenous activists with disabilities from the Pacific on the iPhone camera to create a documentary series on disability and climate change. With VoiceOver, the iPhone provides image descriptions for blind and low-vision filmmakers and offers other accessible features. “If you think about it, it doesn’t make sense for a blind person to use a camera,” says DJP filmmaker Ari Hazelman. “The iPhone gives you more avenues to tell your story in a more profound way as a blind person.”
For Rwandans with DeafBlindness, critical services like healthcare and educational systems rarely offer necessary accommodations like assistive devices and tactile sign language interpretation. Naomi Uwizeyimana shares her experience with inaccessible infrastructure: “You need a person to help you to communicate everywhere you go and to get every service you want, which cannot always be possible.” Her mission is to bridge the gaps and support the DeafBlind community to fully participate in society.
DJP Fellows Esther Suubi and Kinanty Andini both advocate for the rights of persons with psychosocial disabilities through their art and filmmaking, working to create a world free from stigma and discrimination. “I hope that people will realize that mental health is really important, and I hope that many people will not be ashamed if they find out their friends or their family or maybe themselves have mental illness,” says Andini. “We must speak up and prove that the stigmas are wrong.”
For decades, Rwandans with disabilities faced significant challenges to accessing health care. Now the country has embarked on an ambitious plan to renovate all of its outdated facilities, with accessibility as a priority. Thirty health centers have been updated so far, changing stairs into ramps, adding Braille signage and more. “Having access to health services to persons with disability in Rwanda is like dreams that we all wish to be true,” says Aimable Irihose of the Rwanda Organization of Persons with Physical Disabilities and Wheelchair Users.
Terubeimoa (Ruby) Nabetari has been using the skills she learned as a composer of music and drama to help her organization, Te Toa Matoa, get their messages across about the rights of persons with disabilities in Kiribati. When she first became disabled from an accident, “I felt sad and confused … because I was well-known as a person who composed music and drama in my country,” she says. “But as time went on, I thanked God that I changed my mind and started to realize what I have to offer people with disabilities.”