The Right to Health
Play audio version
Indonesian Women with Disabilities Struggle to Access Free Healthcare
July 12, 2022
Translated from Bahasa Indonesia.
Click here for the Bahasa Indonesia version of this article.
MATARAM, Indonesia — According to a 2020 survey by Indonesia’s Central Bureau of Statistics, some 22.5 million people are disabled in Indonesia. In theory, these individuals are entitled to the same affordable and quality healthcare as everyone else. On this point, Indonesia’s 2016 “Law 8 on Persons with Disabilities” is clear: persons with disabilities must have equal access to treatments, medications, and life-saving medical information like how to protect themselves from COVID-19 and other infectious diseases. In 2011, the Indonesian government also ratified the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD), which requires participating nations to “provide persons with disabilities with the same range, quality, and standard of free or affordable health care and programs as provided to other persons.”
But six years after Indonesia passed its disability law and eleven years after it ratified the UNCRPD, Indonesians with disabilities do not have equal access to healthcare. The reasons are myriad and complex. Some relate directly to discrimination (individual and systemic), and some connect to a vicious cycle for many Indonesians with disabilities. Living in poverty because of barriers to education and employment, they can’t afford to pay for healthcare. Forced to go without medical treatment, they become sicker and perhaps more disabled and fall deeper into debt.
Sustia Rini, who goes by “Rini,” is a 37-year-old woman with a disability who lives in Mataram, the capital of the Indonesian province of West Nusa Tenggara. When she was six years old, she developed a high fever, and despite her parents’ best efforts, her illness resulted in a permanent disability – a weakness in her left leg that makes it difficult to walk. In 2005 Rini married, and she and her husband had four children. When she was pregnant with her third child, Rini applied for what is known as a BPJS health insurance card to reduce the cost of giving birth in a hospital. She paid $8 a month in premiums for herself and her family – a fortune for Rini, who did not have a steady income. After giving birth, she decided to stop paying the fees. She wasn’t sick, she reasoned, so why pay for something she wasn’t using? Rini never realized the impact this would have on her and her family. When she needed it most, health insurance would be beyond her grasp.
Healthcare Reform in Indonesia
Since 2014, Indonesia has reformed its national health insurance system to provide healthcare coverage for all Indonesians. National Health Insurance (JKN) is mandatory, universal health insurance. Its intent is to encourage Indonesians to access health services when they need them and to protect against household poverty due to exorbitant medical costs. JKN is managed by the Health Care and Social Security Agency (BPJS). As of 2019, 220 million Indonesians – almost 84 percent of the population – were JKN participants.
Participants are divided into two major groups: premium-assistance beneficiaries (PBI) and non-premium assistance beneficiaries (non-PBI). PBI beneficiaries are the “poor” or “near poor,” and their premiums are covered by the government. Non-PBI beneficiaries include primary workers (those with steady employment); secondary workers (those who have/had/will have temporary employment); and non-workers (those who are unemployed). Referred to as “independent participants,” secondary workers and non-workers within the non-PBI beneficiary group pay independently; employers pay the premiums of primary workers.
When Rini first applied for her insurance card, she did so as an independent participant. After she let her payments lapse for two years, her first child became sick in 2015 and was hospitalized. The medical bills were much more than she could afford, so Rini decided to reapply for Indonesia’s health insurance as a PBI beneficiary. While Rini did qualify as “poor/near poor,” there was a catch. She had to pay off what she owed as an independent participant before she could receive PBI, she was told. Rini was caught in a bind. While she was “poor enough” to qualify for PBI, her lack of income prevented her from paying off her bills so she could receive the free insurance. “As a housewife and head of household, I cannot afford to pay arrears for approximately 8 years,” she says. “That was the obstacle I found when I wanted to make PBI for my family members.” With nowhere to turn, she borrowed money from her brother to pay her son’s hospital bills.
In Indonesia, women with disabilities are often the “poorest of the poor” and are particularly vulnerable to gender-based violence. Rini has been no exception. In 2019, she left her husband because of abuse, and she has not had any type of permanent employment. Now, every time she or someone in her family needs healthcare, she faces difficult choices that could drive her and her children further into poverty.
In Indonesia, many independent participants like Rini don’t pay their premiums. They register when they’re sick and stop paying afterward. According to the Finance Ministry, in 2018 46.3 percent of independent participants did not pay their premiums, resulting in a total debt between 2016 and 2018 of about one billion U.S. dollars. Rini is also not alone in her struggles to get a PBI card. The results of an assessment by the Association of Indonesian Women with Disabilities (HWDI) of NTB Province show as many as 20 women with disabilities in Kediri District, West Lombok Regency, West Nusa Tenggara Province, do not have BPJS cards, both independent and PBI. In addition to the challenge of clearing previous debts, persons with disabilities, especially women, are not registered in the Integrated Social Welfare Data (DTKS). This automatically precludes them from receiving any social assistance, including BPJS PBI.
Hope for Women with Disabilities in West Lombok
In an interview with the Disability Justice Project in June, Nurse H. Zuljipli, M.M., Secretary of the West Lombok District Health Office, said the rules for PBI actually changed in 2020. The West Lombok Regency regional government made a request to BPJS: accept West Lombok residents into the PBI program even if they owe money as former, non-PBI participants. What this means is that West Lombok residents like Rini can now apply for PBI without paying off their debts first. “The poor are certainly people who cannot afford to finance themselves for primary health financing … in outpatient health centers, in inpatients in hospitals,” Zuljipli said. “We prioritize disability.” Upon hearing this news, Rini felt a huge sense of relief – for herself and for all women with disabilities in her community who need free health insurance. She is now preparing to apply for PBI with the help of HWDI of NTB Province.
In his interview with the Disability Justice Project, Zuljipli also said his office has 3000 extra shares of free healthcare to distribute, so organizations like HWDI of NTB Province will begin collecting data on persons with disabilities who do not have BPJS PBI cards, encouraging them to apply. In terms of the DTKS requirement, Zuljipli said that DTKS is indeed necessary for obtaining a BPJS health card if BPJS is funded by the Ministry of Social Affairs. However, since many West Lombok residents are not included in DTKS, the West Lombok Health Office took the initiative to have BPJS funded by the West Lombok Regency local government so that people could register for BPJS PBI without using DTKS requirements.
Rini says free health insurance will have a significant impact on all areas of her life. No longer dependent on others to pay her bills, she and her family will grow stronger and more independent. They will access healthcare when they need it. Today, Rini is studying to become a paralegal so she can assist other women with disabilities who have experienced violence. Her hope is that, at least in her community, she can help reverse some of the devastating statistics that have plagued women with disabilities for too long.
Sri Sukarni is a 2022 DJP Fellow and chairperson of HWDI of NTB Province. @2022 HWDI. All rights reserved.
News From the Global Frontlines of Disability Justice
DJP Fellow Retta Maha is the first blind filmmaker the DJP has worked with, and she’s paved the way in showing how individuals who are blind or low vision can tell video stories: “I found that blind people also can be filmmakers, as long as they get support. The blind have their own idea of … what the story is, and then the sighted people can help them make it real.”
Misconceptions surrounding leprosy continue to have significant impacts in Indonesia, a country with the third-highest incidence of leprosy in the world. In Jongaya, people experiencing leprosy live separately from the rest of the population in South Sulawesi. One former resident shares her story.
Six years after Indonesia passed its disability law and 11 years after it ratified the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, Indonesians with disabilities still do not have equal access to healthcare. Forced to go without medical treatment, many become sicker and perhaps more disabled and fall deeper into debt.
Ariani Soekanwo became a disability rights activist as a college student. Since then, she has helped start several Indonesian disability rights organizations. Age is not an obstacle for her. Her enthusiasm for encouraging the fulfillment of rights for persons with disabilities in Indonesia pushes her to never stop thinking and creating.
After DJP Fellow Naufal Asy-Syaddad was diagnosed with autism, he experienced bullying and exclusion in his early school years. Now, he’s found a home at Yogasmara Foundation, where he advocates for disability rights and raises awareness about autism. People with autism, he says, “are highly misunderstood.”
DJP Fellow Dija spent the beginnings of her life indoors and away from others. “In my village, people with disabilities are pitied,” she says. In recent years, she has been on a mission of acceptance and opportunity for persons with disabilities. No longer afraid to leave her home, Dija draws from her own experiences in her advocacy work.